(NB: Assisting clergy are listed in italics. Rectors are listed in bold.)
Charles Augustus Jessup, DD, Priest-in-Charge - 1886-1891
Ordained Deacon, 1885; Priest, 1886
James Herriot Noble, Lay Reader & Deacon Resident - 1886-1891
Ordained Deacon, 1889; Priest, 1897
Albert Daniels Willson, Lay Reader - 1891-1892
Ordained Deacon, 1893; Priest, 1895
Leon Durand Bonnet, Lay Reader - 1891
Charles Henry Schultz, Priest-in-Charge - 1892-1893
Ordained Deacon and Priest, 1887
John Trappall Matthews, Deacon Resident - 1892-1893
Ordained Deacon, 1892; Priest, 1895
Charles Philip Augustus Burnett, Priest-in-Charge - 1893-1895
Ordained Deacon, 1878; Priest, 1879
George Valerie Gilreath, Priest-in-Charge - 1896-1897
Ordained Deacon, 1894; Priest, 1895
Roelif Hasbrouck Brooks, DD, Lay Reader - 1897-1898
Ordained Deacon, 1902; Priest, 1903
Herbert Justison Glover, Priest-in-Charge - 1898-1902
Ordained Deacon and Priest, 1897
William Dwight Porter Bliss, PhD, Priest-in-Charge - 1902-1907
Ordained Deacon, 1886; Priest, 1887
Henry Lowndes Drew, MA, Priest-in-Charge - 1907-1913
Ordained Deacon, 1903; Priest, 1904
John Whiting Crowell, MA, Deacon Resident & Priest-in-Charge - 1913-1917
Ordained Deacon, 1913; Priest, 1914
Vedder Van Dyck, Priest-in-Charge & Rector - 1917-1929
Ordained Deacon, 1914; Priest, 1915
Frank Caldwell Morrell, Deacon - 1926-1960's; Chaplain to the Bishop of Long Island - 1949-1964
Ordained Deacon, 1917
Bayard Heylin Goodwin, Rector - 1929-1966
Ordained Deacon, 1918; Priest, 1919
Nicholas William Dand, Curate - 1962-1963; Interim Priest - 1975
Ordained Deacon, 1962; Priest, 1963
Mark Antony DeWolf, Rector - 1966-1974
Ordained Deacon, 1959; Priest, 1960
Randolph Jon Geminder, Rector - 1975-present
Ordained Deacon and Priest, 1971
